The second amendment in historical perspective paul finkelman a well regulated militia, composed of gentlemen freeholders, and other freemen, is the natural strength and only stable security of a free government. Did they mean that only those citizens who are organized into official militias by local or. In the houses of parliament, george iii discusses the war with the american colonies, and points out that the colonists outnumber the british. From founding fathers own mouths, what is a well regulated militia. Wellregulated definition of wellregulated by the free. David mcculloughs book 1776 covers just that, the most important year of the revolutionary war. The second amendment you dont know new york daily news. If a liberal education has formed in us well regulated appetites and worthy inclinations. What does the second amendments well regulated really. To understand how training in discipline tie into the meaning of wellregulated, the following passage is helpful. To understand, however, it helps to put yourself in the context of 1789 america. The second amendment, ratified in 1791, is one of 10 amendments that form the bill of rights. That a well regulated militia, composed of the body of the people, trained to arms, is the proper, natural, and safe defence of a free state. It establishes the right to bear arms and figures prominently in the longrunning debate over gun control.
As this book goes to press, there are sixteen gunban bills before the united. A well regulated militia not only restores the lost meaning of the original second amendment, but it provides a clear historical road map that charts how we have arrived at our current impasse over guns. In colonial times the term well regulated meant well functioning. Their central ideology is a strict reading of the second amendments clauses of a well regulated militia and right of the people to keep and bear arms, feeling these protections permit armed insurrection. For anyone interested in understanding the great american gun debate, this is a must read. The second amendment to americas constitution reads. The book has a generous 32 pages of blackandwhite as well as color illustrations. Even though the war does not officially end until the treaty of paris is signed in 1783, the reader follows washington and his men through losses and miserable retreats, as well as his big successes against cornwallis and rall. The most popular grammars in the framers day were written by robert lowth and lindley murray. Cornell, a leading constitutional historian, shows that the founders understood the right to bear arms as neither an individual nor a collective right, but as a civic rightan obligation citizens owed to the state to arm themselves so that they could participate in a well regulated militia. To answer the question presented, we must start out by telling you that there are several opinions as to what the meaning of well regulated militia actually means. I decided to read this book because it is on the best seller list and there are about 350 people who have reserved the book on line at the library. The use of well regulated in this act can shed some light on the meaning of the 2nd amendment.
Well regulated means to be in good condition or to be well kept. Most of the quotes on this page are from thomas paines works the rights of man and the age of reason. A well regulated militia the founding fathers and the origins of gun control in america saul cornell. Punctuation was not an important part of 18thcentury writing instruction. Independence being declared in 1776, the states began adopting bills of. Cottrol is the editor of the book gun control and the constitution. Well regulated doesnt mean what most people think it does denton bramwell, aug 6, 2007 what does well regulated mean. Posted on february 3, 2015 march 12, 2015 by ammoland by samadams1776. This definition wouldnt have been different in 1776. The james madison research library and information center. Understandably the person at the center of the authors book is general george washington. A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. Whereas in all well regulated governments it is the indispensable duty of every legislatures to. Then again, i did not understand why people could not understand shakespeare either.
This choice suggests that the framers were not referring to any particular well regulated militia but, instead, only to the concept that well regulated militias, made up of citizens bearing arms. Such language has created considerable debate regarding the amendments intended scope. According to the father of our country, well regulated means ordered and disciplined not irregular and disjointed, which describes the poorly regulated situation today that has led to the proliferation of guns threatening the security of many americans. May 24, 2005 i decided to read this book because it is on the best seller list and there are about 350 people who have reserved the book on line at the library. James madison, i annals of congress 434, june 8, 1789. The distinction between a well regulated army, and a mob, is the good order and discipline of the first, and the licentious and disorderly behaviour of the latter. Paine moved to england in 1787 and wrote the rights of man in defense of the french revolution. A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed. May 19, 2008 a well regulated definition catching up on my reading the other day, i came across the following quotation. The supreme court was simply affirming what the founding fathers had already established. Well regulated doesnt mean what most people think it does. Dec 25, 2012 the strongest argument for gun control is found in the 2nd amendment itself, which reads.
During the fourth day of the convention, patrick henry put forward a resolutionthat a well regulated militia, composed of gentlemen and yeomen, is the natural strength, and only security, of a free government. Second amendment to the united states constitution wikipedia. Is the supreme court going to define well regulated militia. To discover exactly what the founding generation understood a well regulated militia to mean, all that is necessary is to look at what our ancestors said and wrote regarding exactly who the militia were understood to be and in what context a well regulated militia was used by them within american bills of rights. On 22 october 1776, george washington wrote to one of his officers. A wellregulated militia is a fascinating study into the meaning of the words of the. Supreme court stated that the adjective well regulated implies nothing more than the imposition of proper discipline and. Today, that is a far more accurate description of your national guardsman than it is of joe civilian citizen. Because modern punctuation practice is well regulated, we as 21stcentury readers may be tempted to ascribe more to the second amendments punctuation than is warranted. Therefore theyre attempting to dismantle it piece by piece, using this favorite talking point.
The second amendment to the united states constitution states. From founding fathers own mouths, what is a wellregulated. The meaning of the phrase well regulated in the 2nd amendment from. Do people have the right to bear arms or only well regulated.
The forgotten history of freedmen militias from 1776 until the civil war. A well regulated militia, composed of the body of the people, trained to arms, is the best and most natural defense of a free country. Dec 08, 2019 sir, what did you miss in your civics education. James madison, the constitution of the united states of america. And yet, for years, those 27 brief words have been the source of contentious debate seen by some as an inalienable protection against tyranny. Or, more to the point, what did it mean at the time that the constitution of the united states was being written. A militia is a group of fighters with a common goal. George mason, the history of the second amendment is rooted in english. A well regulated militia, back when, our constitution was written meant every able bodied and armed man who was not in the army whose help could be requested in a time of danger. Well regulated doesnt mean what most people think it does denton bramwell, aug 6, 2007 what does wellregulated mean. This choice suggests that the framers were not referring to any particular well regulated militia but, instead, only to the concept that well regulated militias, made up.
The war of independence was still a fresh memorycloser in time to 1776 than we are today to 911. A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the. Wellregulated definition, to control or direct by a rule, principle, method, etc to regulate household expenses. Associate professor of history, the ohio state university. Thomas jefferson, by no means an imprecise thinker, was well aware of this. Note that in the time when it was written well regulated meant in good working order. This brief textual analysis also suggests to put in good order is the correct interpretation of well regulated, signifying a well disciplined, trained, and functioning militia. They also declared a well regulated militia to be necessary to secure a free state. Carpenter might be overly optimistic in this regard. Rules for membership in the well regulated militia thom. A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep. For a people who are free, and who mean to remain so, a well organized and armed militia is their best security. Well regulated will surely relate to the codification of the militia. The second amendment of the united states constitution reads.
In any case, a well regulated militia is a thoughtprovoking and very timely read. A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state. Beyond any doubt, he is spoton about the dangers presented by our wide open borders. Well regulated definition, to control or direct by a rule, principle, method, etc to regulate household expenses. But theyre going to have a tough time just writing it out of existence. Explore militia quotes by authors including thomas jefferson, james monroe, and john adams at brainyquote. The right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. So, about that wellregulated militia part of the constitution. The work is a companion to mcculloughs earlier biography of john adams, and focuses on the events surrounding the start of the american revolution.
Times, sunday times 2017 the classic definition of uniform isolates three principles that contribute to the power of a wellregulated and symbolically loaded outfit. The subject matter and unusual phrasing of this amendment led to much controversy and analysis, especially in the last half of the twentieth century. A wellregulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. The founders liked militias, but they also liked an armed citizenry. The distinction between a well regulated army and a mob is the good order and discipline of the first, and the licentious and disorderly behavior of the latter. Apr 03, 2018 what the media isnt telling you about the trump impeachment inquiry duration.
The biggest threat to liberty is a tyrannical government backed by a large standing army. The three percenters are a national group that was loosely organized in 2008 by mike vanderboegh, the late militia leader and author of the controversial novel, absolved. Jun 20, 2016 the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. Read thomas paine quotes from his own writings and letters from the years 1775 and 1776. Apr 11, 2018 again, what is the meaning of well regulated. A wellregulated definition catching up on my reading the other day, i came across the following quotation. In historical terms, and today, what does wellregulated. Attending were 120 delegates from all parts of the colony. The man and the movement he inspired broadside books. To bear arms did not simply mean to carry firearms. But what experiences led the founders to adopt it, and what did it mean to them. A wellregulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the. Therefore, even if the opening words of the amendment, a well regulated militia. On the one hand, some believe that the amendments phrase the right of the.
Many of the mps members of parliament, such as lord sandwich, first lord of the admiralty, assure george that the americans dont pose a serious threat because they lack discipline. Schultz further expounds upon the meaning wellregulated at the time the second amendment was written, and in the context of the rest of the constitution. Director of the second amendment research center, john glenn institute for public service and public policy glenn institute. Wellregulated definition and meaning collins english. The strongest argument for gun control is found in the 2nd amendment itself, which reads. May 21, 2019 personally i do not see the confusion. It is considering a guncontrol case in which it might choose to rule on what the second amendment means. What was meant in those days by a militia and what should it be taken to mean now. In a wellregulated body clock the hormone is highest in the evening and at low levels by early morning.
A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of. In the coming months, as the nation begins a serious discussion about gun regulation, the meaning of the second amendment the statement that a well regulated militia, being necessary to the. Feb 06, 2012 from founding fathers own mouths, what is a wellregulated militia. The book is about the revolutionary war in the year 1776. Image via wikipedia heres a collection of quotes from the revolutionaries who were there at that moment in history when the united states constitution got ratified, together with the bill of rights, including the second amendment. The intent of the second amendment is often debated. In other words, it didnt mean the state was controlling the militia in a certain way. The ideological background of the second amendment, the plain meaning of its operative clause. In the 18th century, to bear arms also meant to participate in a militia.
What is a well regulated militia and what is its purpose. And finally, when regulated is used as an adjective, its meaning varies depending on. A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security. It focused on the idea that the nobility did not have an inherent right to govern the. Second amendment legal definition of second amendment. A wellregulated militia saul cornell oxford university press. One of the puzzles of the second amendment to me at least is the use of the opening phrase a well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state to justify the right of the people to keep and bear arms. Halonen the following are taken from the oxford english dictionary, and bracket in time the writing of the 2nd amendment 1709. The practice of all well regulated courts of justice in the world. A well regulated militia a refresher for liberal education victims ammoland inc. A well regulated militia would mean a group of people that are capable of fighting for a common cause. So the original definition of a well regulated militia describes an american well skilled in the use of a firearm, and able to march, fight, and be militarily effective under their elected officers.
519 715 1395 895 706 1349 1315 585 784 428 33 31 687 249 424 436 1006 1334 418 145 440 227 224 510 897 145 1270 1137 395 197 661 1425 207 258 1184 428 254 432 44 1255 1482 1019 170 1373 1129 794 1491